|
15 August 2003
How To Draw Schematic
Diagrams
By Paul Horowitz and Winfield
Hill
Appendix E
from The
Art of Electronics 2nd Edition
A
well-drawn schematic makes it easy to understand how a circuit works and
aids in troubleshooting; a poor schematic only creates confusion. By keeping
a few rules and suggestions in mind, you can draw a good schematic in
no more time than it takes to draw a poor one. In this appendix we dispense
advice of three varieties: general principles, rules, and hints. We have
also drawn some real knee-slappers to illustrate habits to avoid.
General Principles
- Schematics should be unambiguous.
Therefore, pin numbers, parts values, polarities, etc., should be clearly
labeled to avoid confusion.
- A good schematic makes
circuit functions clear. Therefore, keep functional areas distinct;
don't be afraid to leave blank areas on the page, and don't try to fill
the page. There are conventional ways to draw functional subunits; for
instance, don't draw a differential amplifier as in Figure E1, because
the function won't be easily recognized. Likewise, flip-flops are usually
drawn with clock and inputs on the left, set and clear on top and bottom,
and outputs on the right.
|

Figure
E1: Placement of power rails and conventions for device alignment
(examples of what not to do)Click image to enlarge
|
Rules
- Wires connecting are indicated
by a heavy black dot; wires crossing, but not connecting, have no dot
(don't use a little half-circular ``jog''; it went out in the 1950s).
- Four wires must not connect
at a point; i.e., wires must not cross and connect.
- Always use the same symbol
for the same device; e.g., don't draw flip-flops in two different ways
(exception: assertion-level logic symbols show each gate in two possible
ways).
- Wires and components are
aligned horizontally or vertically, unless there's a good reason to
do otherwise.
- Label pin numbers on the
outside of a symbol, signal names on the inside.
- All parts should have values
or types indicated; it's best to give all parts a label, too, e.g.,
R7 or IC3.
Hints
- Identify parts immediately
adjacent to the symbol, forming a distinct group giving symbol, label,
and type or value.
- In general, signals go
from left to right; don't be dogmatic about this, though, if clarity
is sacrificed.
- Put positive supply voltages
at the top of the page, negative at the bottom. Thus, npn transistors
will usually have their emitter at the bottom, whereas pnp's
will have their emitter topmost.
- Don't attempt to bring
all wires around to the supply rails, or to a common ground wire. Instead,
use the ground symbol(s) and labels like +Vcc to indicate those voltages
where needed.
- It is helpful to label
signals and functional blocks and show waveforms; in logic diagrams
it is especially important to label signal lines, e.g., RESET' or CLK.
- It is helpful to bring
leads away from components a short distance before making connections
or jogs. For example, draw transistors as in Figure E2.
|

Figure
E2: Component leads. Click image to enlarge.
|
- Leave some space around
circuit symbols; e.g., don't draw components or wires too close to an
op-amp symbol. This keeps the drawing uncluttered and leaves room for
labels, pin numbers, etc.
- Label all boxes that aren't
obvious: comparator versus op-amp, shift register versus counter, etc.
Don't be afraid to invent a new symbol.
- Use small rectangles, ovals,
or circles to indicate card-edge connections, connector pins, etc. Be
consistent.
- The signal path through
switches should be clear. Don't force the reader to follow wires all
over the page to find out how a signal is switched.
- Power-supply connections
are normally assumed for op-amps and logic devices. However, show any
unusual connections (e.g., an op-amp run from a single supply, where
V- = ground) and the disposition of unused inputs.
- It is very helpful to include
a small table of IC numbers, types, and power-supply connections (pin
numbers for Vcc and ground, for instance).
- Include a title area near
the bottom of the page, with name of circuit, name of instrument, by
whom drawn, by whom designed or checked, date, and assembly number.
Also include a revision area, with columns for revision number, date,
and subject.
- We recommend drawing schematics
freehand on coarse graph paper (nonreproducing blue, 4 to 8 lines per
inch) or on plain paper on top of graph paper. This is fast, and it
gives very pleasing results. Use dark pencil or ink; avoid ball-point
pen.
As an illustration, we've drawn
a humble example (Figure E3) showing ``awful'' and ``good'' schematics of
the same circuit; the former violates nearly every rule and is almost impossible
to understand. See how many bad habits you can find illustrated. We've seen
all of them in professionally drawn schematics! (Drawing the ``bad'' schematic
was an occasion of great hilarity; we laughed ourselves silly.)
|

Figure
E3 (A): An awful schem. Click image to enlarge
|
|

Figure
E3 (B): A good schematic. Click image to enlarge
|
|